I glued all my NOS neoprene tips on with super glue, and after a few weeks of playing, they started falling off.

I removed them all, I'm scraping the wood portion of the hammer clean with a razor (which I originally did, painstakingly, with all the old tips), and I'm starting over.
I tried Gorilla Glue. Worse than the super glue.
I tried Amazing Goop. Worse yet.
I have a gig on Saturday, and all my hammer tips are in a plastic bag.
:shock:
A little help, please? (I really don't want to haul the Hammond to the gig...)