News:

Don't forget to read the forum rules.

Main Menu

MISSING NOTES IN SUSTAIN 200A

Started by Electrickey, May 30, 2013, 06:46:54 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Electrickey

What is happening when holding down the sustain pedal on a 200A, the notes randomly disappear when striking a key? The hammers do not hit the reeds consistently.

Max Brink

It's likely that the fly is not returning to position properly because it's not regulated properly or not able to be regulated properly (without replacing parts).

When the sustain pedal is not held down, the spring at the end of the damper arm can add tension that helps return the fly into place for the next key strike. If there is 1) excessive lost motion, 2) if the flanges are too stiff/tight, 3) or if the jack spring is wearing down then the fly does not return to place and it may be impossible to play with dynamics.


Potential solutions depending on the degree of the problem:

1) Regulate lost motion

2) Treat the flanges with the Napthta/oil solution in the manual

3) Replace the jack springs


...Hopefully a combination of one and two is all it needs.
Max Brink
The Chicago Electric Piano Co.

ph: (312)476-9528
e: max@chicagoelectricpiano.com

w: http://www.chicagoelectricpiano.com/
fb: http://facebook.com/electricpianoco/
tw&ig: @electricpianoco

Electrickey

#2
Quote from: Max Brink on May 30, 2013, 08:54:43 AM
It's likely that the fly is not returning to position properly because it's not regulated properly or not able to be regulated properly (without replacing parts).

When the sustain pedal is not held down, the spring at the end of the damper arm can add tension that helps return the fly into place for the next key strike. If there is 1) excessive lost motion, 2) if the flanges are too stiff/tight, 3) or if the jack spring is wearing down then the fly does not return to place and it may be impossible to play with dynamics.


Potential solutions depending on the degree of the problem:

1) Regulate lost motion

2) Treat the flanges with the Napthta/oil solution in the manual

3) Replace the jack springs


...Hopefully a combination of one and two is all it needs.

Thanks, Max. Yes hopefully its adjustment and lubrication. At least you've isolated the area to look at for me.

pianotuner steveo

Always look for the cheapest/ easiest solutions first.
Determine if the keys are slow to return or if it is the action. It could be as simple as easing key bushings and lubing the balance rail pins.
My next guess would be lubing the action flanges. If it is in a humid room, such as a basement, try using a dehumidifier.

If you can get protek, it is the best lubricant for pianos. The naptha/ mineral oil solution is more readily available, but protek does work better.

1960 Wurlitzer model 700 EP
1968 Gibson G101 Combo organ
1975 Rhodes Piano Bass
1979 Wurlitzer 206A EP
2009 73A Rhodes Mark 7
2009 Korg SV-1 73
2017 Yamaha P255
2020 Kawai CA99
....and a few guitars...

Electrickey

Quote from: pianotuner steveo on May 31, 2013, 07:54:04 AM
Always look for the cheapest/ easiest solutions first.
Determine if the keys are slow to return or if it is the action. It could be as simple as easing key bushings and lubing the balance rail pins.
My next guess would be lubing the action flanges. If it is in a humid room, such as a basement, try using a dehumidifier.

If you can get protek, it is the best lubricant for pianos. The naptha/ mineral oil solution is more readily available, but protek does work better.

Steveo, thanks.

Electrickey

I'm not a piano technician and my piano tech is asking:

Would anyone know adjustment figures for the following, for the 200A in terms of numbers, millimeters or inches?

(1) What is the blow distance from hammer to the reed?

(2) What is the let-off distance of the jack before hitting the reed?

Do these figures exist or is it all eyeball and ballpark? 

pianotuner steveo

Blow distance is preset on the piano and never needs changing unless someone messed with it. The hammers rest on a rail that is a preset distance,it is possible to decrease the measurement, but not possible to increase it. The service manual states that this distance is preset at 1 1/8", from the hammer tip to the bottom side of the reed.

The let off distance (per the manual) is 1/8" in the 200 series action, BUT, I am a professional piano tech and I have found that slightly increasing the distance in the tenor and treble GREATLY reduces broken reeds from heavy playing.

3/16" is usually pretty good.

1960 Wurlitzer model 700 EP
1968 Gibson G101 Combo organ
1975 Rhodes Piano Bass
1979 Wurlitzer 206A EP
2009 73A Rhodes Mark 7
2009 Korg SV-1 73
2017 Yamaha P255
2020 Kawai CA99
....and a few guitars...

Max Brink

#7
QuoteI have found that slightly increasing the distance in the tenor and treble GREATLY reduces broken reeds from heavy playing.

I disagree and have found the opposite to be the best for an even dynamic setup across the keyboard.

The let-off regulation directly affects the dynamic range of the note and have found that it is best set at an average distance of roughly 1/8" starting on the lowest bass notes and getting within 1/16" in the upper treble. I find this ballpark to be the best for balancing the left and right hand's dynamic range. The parameters are going to be a little different piano to piano and some notes will need more or less let-off than others so you will want to fine tune various notes after hearing it through the amplifier.

As long as the hammer is letting off before hitting the reed then the reed does not "know" at what distance the hammer was let-off. The reed only "knows" the velocity of the hammer striking it. Regulating at less than 1/8" will not result in broken reeds and will allow you to get an articulate strike with a much softer touch.

I guarantee all of my work and cover all of my repairs with an open ended warranty--I cover any of my work that is not satisfactory within a reasonable period of time under reasonable use of the instrument. In this case I would cover broken reeds up a few years depending on the use of the instrument if it was the result of the regulation (longer time frame for a studio/home shorter if it is traveling/gigging and handled more regularly but in the end I'd probably work out something reasonable to take care of my client)... To this day I have never heard of a single reed breaking in a Wurlitzer that was properly setup in my workshop (knock on wood).
Max Brink
The Chicago Electric Piano Co.

ph: (312)476-9528
e: max@chicagoelectricpiano.com

w: http://www.chicagoelectricpiano.com/
fb: http://facebook.com/electricpianoco/
tw&ig: @electricpianoco

pianotuner steveo

#8
Well we agree to disagree then.

Letoff being too close also can cause broken strings in acoustic pianos, especially in grands. I have three customers that kept breaking strings in their grands. I increased the letoff slightly, the broken strings stopped, and not one client complained about feel or dynamics.

I am talking about people who hit HARD, not the average player.

The opposite way, IE your way, can cause hammers to block against the reeds, or broken reeds.

Its all personal preference, neither way is right or wrong, but I have not broken ONE reed since I started increasing the letoff.

Again,
Im not talking about increasing it so much that it makes it feel or sound drastically different.
1960 Wurlitzer model 700 EP
1968 Gibson G101 Combo organ
1975 Rhodes Piano Bass
1979 Wurlitzer 206A EP
2009 73A Rhodes Mark 7
2009 Korg SV-1 73
2017 Yamaha P255
2020 Kawai CA99
....and a few guitars...

Max Brink

#9
QuoteI am talking about people who hit HARD, not the average player.

...But it doesn't matter how HARD you hit it. Decreasing the distance will give you a lot more space to play softly but does not increase the potential range of velocity to a dangerous range. You can play just as HARD with increased let-off distance by playing HARD...


QuoteThe opposite way, IE your way, can cause hammers to block against the reeds

This is true if you are not aware of the other regulation parameters. But this can be safely avoided by proper regulation as well. If the hammer is blocking against the reed, there is probably "negative" lost motion (the lost motion is set to a point that is even less than 0-1/32") OR because there is too much key dip. Increasing a little lost motion should allow the hammer to return to a safe position even within 1/16" in most cases but if that doesn't solve the problem it can also be regulated by decreasing the key dip back down to ~13/32".
Max Brink
The Chicago Electric Piano Co.

ph: (312)476-9528
e: max@chicagoelectricpiano.com

w: http://www.chicagoelectricpiano.com/
fb: http://facebook.com/electricpianoco/
tw&ig: @electricpianoco

pianotuner steveo

#10
But increasing the letoff distance takes some of the intitial force out of the hammer hitting the reed.
The greater the distance = less intitial impact on the reed = less chance of broken reeds.

If letoff is set real close, a LIGHT touch CAN cause hammer blocking. Yes, lost motion and key dip are factors also.

I'm not sure where you are getting your info from regarding letoff not affecting broken reeds.



1960 Wurlitzer model 700 EP
1968 Gibson G101 Combo organ
1975 Rhodes Piano Bass
1979 Wurlitzer 206A EP
2009 73A Rhodes Mark 7
2009 Korg SV-1 73
2017 Yamaha P255
2020 Kawai CA99
....and a few guitars...

Max Brink

#11
--You are correct, Steveo, that you can overcome the problem by increasing the let-off distance, but just because you are having reed blockage doesn't mean that your Wurlitzer is incapable of being regulated for a more expressive touch than that.


QuoteThe greater the distance = less intitial impact on the reed.

That is likely true but not necessarily always true. The let-off doesn't set a max or minimum speed, it only regulates how long speed can be transfered to the hammer's throw by the fly, right? So in the case of regulating the let-off the goal is to give the widest range of dynamics possible so that the player can play as softly or loudly as they would like with ease. It is just as likely that a player can play just as hard with various let-off distances but what's more important is the range of dynamics that the player is able to achieve.


QuoteIf letoff is set real close, a LIGHT touch CAN  cause hammer blocking.

Yes, but... The hammer blocking can be overcome by regulating other aspects of the action assembly. If your let-off is set that close and it is blocking while regulated within that range then you likely have incorrect lost motion or incorrect key dip parameters... Or in very rare cases the action assembly is out of alignment with itself and the main rail can be shimmed to bring it back into proper alignment.
Max Brink
The Chicago Electric Piano Co.

ph: (312)476-9528
e: max@chicagoelectricpiano.com

w: http://www.chicagoelectricpiano.com/
fb: http://facebook.com/electricpianoco/
tw&ig: @electricpianoco

Electrickey

Thank you Steve and Max for the information and insight. That number's 1 & 2 were also followed, specially the naptha/oil application, the action on the 200A livened up considerably and the missing notes came back.

My technician, not versed on a Wurli, working on mainly acoustic pianos and grands, was directed much better by your help on the intricacies of the 200A's system.

Being too far away from those expert on these units, I had no choice but to source a basic piano tech, a second generation piano tech whose family also hand-built their own pianos.

Although he was trained at the Bosendorfer factory in Austria and Vienna, he was trained to use talcum powder on the moving felt parts. A technique he tried as a preliminary solution before going to the naptha/oil. He did not have Protek either so will source some of that for future. My tech remarked that focusing on the let-off adjustment was also key to his getting closer to fixing the problem.